Changing the VAR order before the derby could cause legal problems

The change of group that dominated the VAR in the match between São Paulo and Palmeiras, this Monday (20), in Morumbi, could have penalties. That’s as a result of the Brazilian Football Confederation (CBF), which is chargeable for organizing the Brazilian Championship, in idea has no respect for the Fan Statute, which stipulates that referees should be launched not more than 48 hours (two days). ) before the recreation. The confederation changed Rafael Traci and Helton Nunes after the duo’s efficiency at Internacional x Botafogo, which occurred a day before Choque-Rei. Specialists who heard Lei em Campo commented on the state of affairs.

“Undoubtedly, there’s a violation of the regulation. But I don’t see it as critical sufficient to cancel the match. In this case, the penalties of elimination or elimination of the leaders and a nice could also be applicable”, assess- weight by Gustavo Lopes, a lawyer specializing in sports activities regulation and columnist at Lei em Campo.

READ ALSO: Marco Aurélio Cunha pressures Ceni for placing Miranda in Choque-Rei: “Hot recreation and funky defender”

“We have a couple of drawback on this case. The arbitration change is clearly in violation of federal regulation, which in itself is critical and could convey a sequence of problems for the competitors and the organizer, comparable to a last cancellation or suspension of the match.The fan filed a preliminary injunction right now (Monday) that he could presumably droop the match or reverse the referee change.However, the huge drawback I see with this substitution is that it displays a standard observe in Brazilian sport regulation: the administrative penalty of arbitration, with out utilizing the construction of Sports Justice.The pretext of technical overview has been used for years as a method of administrative punishment of referees , breaking the regulation ”, criticized Vinicius Loureiro, a lawyer specializing in sports activities regulation. and columnist at Lei em Campo.

Attorney Carlos Ramalho confused that “the Fan Statute has the energy to grant privileges on the precept of transparency and impartiality relating to the number of referees”. “In my opinion, other than the components of power majeure, that are justified by the referee, comparable to points involving well being, there’s a mockery of the governing laws (Fan’s Statute) to exchange the referee on match day. Affront, in keeping with artwork. 32 of the EDT, are accountable for nullity and it’s inside the rights of the EDT to precise their proper to what they contemplate to be dangerous ”, he analyzes.

Luiza Soares, a lawyer specializing in sports activities regulation, confused that “the definition of superior arbitration assigned for every recreation is a proper of followers relating to the integrity of competitions”.

“It isn’t any coincidence that it is a provision of the Fan Statute, laws that values ​​fan security in lots of points. Competition”, he added.

What does the article say? 32 of the Fan Statute?

Art. 32. The fan’s proper that the referees of every match be chosen by drawing tons, amongst these beforehand chosen, or by public listening to broadcast stay on the world broad internet, topic to the penalty of nullity.

§ 1 The draw or public listening to shall be held at the least forty-eight hours before every spherical, at the appointed place and date.

§ 2 The lottery is open to the public, which ensures its broad distribution.

perceive the case

CBF introduced on Monday morning, lower than 12 hours before the match between São Paulo x Palmeiras, the substitute of Rafael Traci and Helton Nunes, who’re scheduled to work as VAR and help in the derby, by Rodrigo Guarizo Ferreira do Amaral. Vitor Carmona Metastaine.

The change was impressed by the duo’s efficiency in the match between Internacional and Botafogo, on Sunday, in Beira-Rio.

The transfer made them “beneath analysis of their technical efficiency”, as CBF mentioned in a word, a penalty in favor of Internacional at the begin of the match, which transformed midfielder Edenílson. In the transfer, the Botafogo participant was nonetheless fired.

On the subject, Palmeiras beat São Paulo 2 to 1. The match, regardless of the VAR change, had controversial bids.

Exchange, Order, VAR, Classic, Cause, Problem, Legal


Leave a Comment